Scott Turow begins Presumed Innocent with Rusty Sabich, Kindle County’s chief deputy prosecutor, relating his usual opening speech to a jury in a criminal case.
It is their job, he always says, to determine “what actually occurred.”
When Carolyn Polhemus, another deputy prosecutor, is found raped and murdered, Randy’s boss, who is fighting for his job in a hot election, assigns the investigation to Randy.
The boss doesn’t know Randy had a brief affair with Carolyn, who dumped him a few months before.
When Raymond Horgan loses the election, the newly-elected prosecuting attorney acts swiftly to show voters they made the right choice.
Randy suddenly finds himself accused of Carolyn’s murder.
A lawyer himself, Turow uses his insider’s knowledge of the legal system to allow readers to get a close-up look through Randy’s eyes at the police, the prosecution, the defense team, and the judge.
We see even Randy’s most loyal supporters entertain suspicions about his guilt as as his case sometimes takes on the appearance of a political rivalry.
Readers, too, may wonder if Randy is guilty.
Turow gets details right without sacrificing a good story. He ends with Randy presenting his closing argument, not to a jury but to himself.
Presumed Innocent by Scott Turow
Farrar, Straus, Giroux. ©1987. 431 p.
1987 bestseller #7; my grade: A
©2019 Linda G. Aragoni